Andrew J. Cordaro, M.D.

October 9, 1944 ~ November 4, 2022 (age 78) 78 Years Old
Read more about the life story of Andrew and share your memory.    


Dr. Andrew J. Cordaro, Jr., "the Captain," 78, of Mount Vernon, NY, passed away on November 4, 2022 surrounded by loved ones at New York Presbyterian Westchester Hospital.


Andy was born on October 9, 1944 to Catherine and Andrew J. Cordaro, Sr. in the Bronx, NY. After graduating from Mount St. Michael High School, he went on to study at Fordham University.


While at Fordham, he played football and rugby, leading his teams both as a player and coach. Even after graduation, he tirelessly supported the teams in the stands and as an integral member of the Gridiron Club. For over 20 years, he ran their golf outings where everyone looked forward to Andy taking over the mic as emcee to give away the always interesting array of gifts and prizes.


After Fordham, Andy went on to medical school at Università di Bologna in Italy. In addition to studying medicine esclusivamente in Italiano, he traveled the country playing for the Viro Bologna rugby team.


Back in the states, he completed his residency at Cabrini Medical Center in Manhattan. It was here that he met his wife, Susan, a nurse in the operating room at the time. They wed in 1973, going on to have 2 children, Justin and Andrea, and then 2 grandchildren, Anthony and Amelia.


More recently, Andy spent much of his time supporting Sts. Peter and Paul Church, utilizing his expertise in running golf outings and innovative fundraisers to run church golf outings and events like “Honeymooners’ Night," complete with accompanying trivia and prizes.


If he could have his way, Andy would spend any chance he could down in the Florida Keys casting his fishing line off the dock with Susan by his side, watching the sun set.


Andy was predeceased by his mother and father, Andrew and Catherine Cordaro, his sister Barbara Clark; and brothers-in-law Ronald Tavaska and James Callahan.  He is survived by his wife Susan; his son, Justin and husband Paul Hagen; daughter Andrea and husband Justin Trumbull and their children, Anthony and Amelia; and sister Jeannette Tavaska. He will be missed by friends and extended family including brother-in-law Lawrence Clark; sister-in-law Lisa Callahan; sister-in-law Linda Spero and her husband Richard; brother-in-law Peter Dumas and wife Lenore as well as many nieces and nephews.


To send flowers to the family or plant a tree in memory of Andrew J. Cordaro, M.D., please visit our floral store.


November 7, 2022

4:00 PM to 8:00 PM
Yannantuono Burr Davis Sharpe Funeral Home
584 Gramatan Avenue
Mt. Vernon, NY 10552

Funeral Mass
November 8, 2022

10:45 AM
Sts. Peter & Paul-St. Ursula Church
129 East Birch Street
Mount Vernon, NY 10552

Online Memory & Photo Sharing Event
Online Event


In Loving Memory Of

Andrew Cordaro, M.D.

October 9, 1944-November 4, 2022

Look inside to read what others have shared

Family and friends are coming together online to create a special keepsake. Every memory left on the online obituary will be automatically included in the book.   


© 2022 Yannantuono Burr Davis Sharpe Funeral Home. All Rights Reserved. Funeral Home website by CFS & TA | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Accessibility